FANDOM


I want to point something out.Phoebe regains her levitation power between Forever Charmed and No Rest for the Wicca.Not in that specific issue!Plus,she regains her empathy power in Innocents Lost(specific issue),not before that!85.75.113.106 09:22, October 25, 2010 (UTC)

I think its a smarter idea to keep the character development presented in the series and comics separate; Brad Kern and Constance M. Burge did a far better job of writing the series than what the writers of the comics are doing. The same goes for the novels, the comics and books are based on the series, they are not directly continued or linked. When it comes to articles on powers and things of that sort, I think its important to label the paragraph(s) as ==Powers in the Comics== --HalliwellManorAkaDsc385 09:39, October 25, 2010 (UTC)


So what do you suggest we do....?Do you have an idea...?The books and the novels timeline is totaly different!

What is the most appropriate of theesw two to follow...??Comics or Novels?85.75.113.106 09:46, October 25, 2010 (UTC)

The comics are counted as canon. They're seen as the season 9. If you think Brad and Connie did a better job at writing, it's your own opinion. I personally like how the comics are going.
Phoebe regained both her powers back between Forever Charmed and No Rest for the Wicca. --GlennVP 15:25, October 25, 2010 (UTC)
Ok then.But if we count the comics as canon.Someone should change what im saying!Phoebe regained her empathy in Innocents Lost.Her levitation power was regained at some point between Forever Charmed and No Rest for the Wicca!Ok?Correct the information on Phoebes section in that page.85.75.108.142 21:22, October 25, 2010 (UTC)
She regained her empathy before Innocents Lost, didn't she? She didn't gain it in the actual issue, not? --GlennVP 16:15, October 26, 2010 (UTC)
I have the same question as you my friend.According to the charmed comics Phoebe has already regained her Levitation power.However her Empathy power is returned to her in the issue Innocents Lost!Not before that issue.Now,according to the charmed novels she regains her Empathy power at some point between Forever Charmed and the novel Trickery Treat,which takes place 5 months after Forever Charmed.Which of theese two alternative choices do we have to follow...???85.75.80.202 09:28, October 29, 2010 (UTC)
We follow the comics as those are counted canon. The novels are not counted as canon, and thus don't matter. --GlennVP 20:37, October 29, 2010 (UTC)
Ok then!I fyou follow the comics order you should know what i am saying.Phoebe regained her levitation at some point between Forever Charmed and Charmed Lives.Her empathy power was regained in the issue Innocents Lost,not before that!(according to the comics order)
I think you should make the necessary changes in this page and also on Phoebes page,there are some mistakes regarding her powers timeline.85.75.95.33 21:01, October 29, 2010 (UTC)

Infobox

Generaly I would like to see the Charmedones exactly previous infoboxes return!As they were more accurate!85.75.95.33 21:24, October 29, 2010 (UTC)

connection

Prue's and Paige's power connection is movement, and Phoebe's connection is the mind or psychic energy.201.239.95.229 02:09, December 5, 2010 (UTC)

Granting Powers

How else do magical beings possess more powers..........because the Elders grant powers to them. Jessica  Talk  Contribs  Email 

I don't remember who said it, but the Elders do not grant powers, they don't have that ability. Powers are tied to emotions, at least that's how it work on magical witches. Ex: Prue developed naturally Astral Projection, also she wanted desperatly to be in two places at time. Ex 2: Piper's Molecular combustion power developed when her emotions and acttitude became more agresive, it is also a natural advancement. Conclusion: The writers messed up saying that "they" gave her the combustion power. --Dyego Simpson 01:13, December 6, 2010 (UTC)

I agree. Their powers were naturally growing. The Elders grant powers as a result of turning people into whitelighters, though.174.64.173.18 21:23, October 6, 2014 (UTC)Logan

I think the Elder control when to give the powers they dont have control over what the power is.Kt111 19:52, April 26, 2011 (UTC)

I really do think it was just a mistake on the writer's parts. I don't see how their powers can be naturally advancing yet be given to them at the same time; it wouldn't be natural then.174.64.173.18 21:23, October 6, 2014 (UTC)Logan

Organization

Am I the only one who thinks this article is somewhat sloppy? There are images all over the page and it doesn't look clean at all. For instance, what is with the tiny pictures of who the Charmed Ones are when describing their powers, why are the pictures on the right side? There is also no heading or explanation as to what is seen in the pictures provided.--HalliwellManorAkaDsc385 01:23, January 8, 2011 (UTC)

Telepathy

Paige has a telepathic not telempathic connection with her charges. And i think Phoebe's connection should be psychic, psychomagnetic, or psionic energy.201.239.95.25 23:12, February 23, 2011 (UTC)


New Charmed ones

Are wyatt, chris and melinda the new charmed ones?Just a Witch 18:13, March 9, 2011 (UTC)

I cant rememeber what issue, i think it's the heir up their, where it's stated that the first three born would be the new charmed ones, and i think because they are all now twice-blessed, that they're a more powerfull force of good than the charmed ones. Although, i'm not entirley sure, please correct me if i'm wrong. PrescottStreet18:22, March 9, 2011 (UTC) You are right it's the heir up there. but if they are chosen to be the future charmed ones shouldn't we add it on their pages?Just a Witch 18:27, March 9, 2011 (UTC)

PrescottStreet, your right. Even I've readed the issue I was left confused. They never explained when they'll became Charmed, because they'll have to inherit the power of three first and Piper, Phoebe and Paige are all still alive. They can't inherit something that someone else already possess. And if the sisters all live until old age, Wyatt Chris and Melinda will be old before they get the power of three. One of the sisters will have to die young for them to inherit the power at a young age--Superlana 18:30, March 9, 2011 (UTC)

Kyle never said that they definantally would become charmed, he said that the Elders only hoped they would become charmed. So nothing's confirmed. Shanebeckam 18:42, March 9, 2011 (UTC)


It's only logical that they'll become the new Charmed Ones.
@Superlana: The sisters don't have to die in order for Wyatt, Chris and Melinda to inherit the Power of Three. Demons like Patra, Pilar and Phoenix tapped into it and stole it. Piper, Penny and Patty used it when the sisters during the Ultimate Battle, etc. The Power of Three is something you have to tap into to. Both the sisters as the new Charmed Ones will be able to use it. --PerryPeverell - (talk) - (contributions) 18:49, March 9, 2011 (UTC)
@PerryPeverell - wasn't it said that they are an even more powerful force of good than the charmed ones becuase they are all twice-blessed?
Yeah, the Elders altered the prophecy and made Chris and Melinda twice blessed as well, which is why they will be more powerful then the first Charmed Ones. --PerryPeverell - (talk) - (contributions) 19:18, March 9, 2011 (UTC)
Just my opinion, but I'm not sure i actually like that they'll become the new Charmed Ones.Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com 17:08, March 11, 2011 (UTC)

It could easily be different family members that become the next Charmed Ones. Wyatt, PJ, and Tamora/Kat (whoever was born first), could become the next charmed ones, since they are the oldest offsprings of the Charmed Ones. Or it could be Phoebe's daughters. Just because the Elders hoped that they would become the next Charmed Ones, doesn't neccissarily mean they will. Shanebeckam 05:44, March 12, 2011 (UTC)

I get that they wanted a more powerful set of charmed ones, but the prophecy was about three sisters with different powers (molecular immobilization, telekinesis and premonition) Wyatt, Melinda and Chris have the same power of telekinesis.201.239.95.71 00:29, March 17, 2011 (UTC)

Let's Clarify - The Elders are not changing the actually prophecy itself, they are not changing the destiny of Piper, Phoebe and Paige. Knowing that the sisters would eventually die or retire from the craft, they want someone to continue the legacy of the Power of Three, therefore, after seeing how powerful Wyatt is, the Elders intervened with Chris and Melinda, bestowing them with the same twice blessed powers Wyatt was born with. They are not the new Charmed Ones, nor are they the new Power of Three. The children will simply have the power to continue the Charmed Ones destiny and legacy of battling evil after the sisters die, they will possibly be more powerful than the sisters because they are half whitelighter and have the ability to remain in constant contact with Elders, that is all that is meant. 216.174.136.2 01:03, March 17, 2011 (UTC)
Then charmed one status should be removed from Wyatt, Chris and Melinda's infoboxes as well as the high resistance when in unity power.201.239.95.71 01:17, March 17, 2011 (UTC)
For that matter the rest of the cousins with the exception of Henry Jr should also continue the legacy.201.239.95.71 01:19, March 17, 2011 (UTC)
its not just pipers kids it could also be phoeboes since she has three daughters and paige kind of gets out of the question because she has 2 children and one addopted it also states in phoeboes daughter and pipers children wiki page that if the need is great enough they may inherite the power of three.IT was suppost to be pipers kids and plus they twice blessed them but the angel of destiny took the twice belssed way and said that anyone fo the kids not only piper for ex:phoeboes daughter could inhert the power of three naturally without the help of the elderds it up to destiny to who get the power of three either phoebo or pipers kids but since most demons are killed i dought they will ever need to gain the power of 3 but i think phoebo daughter will since it the charmed ones were 3 girls and wouldnt it be cool the power of 9 all the charmed kids evil wouldnt stand a chance

Question About The Prophecy




You can kill me, but you cannot kill my kind. The Warren line will grow stronger with each generation, culminating in the arrival of three sisters. They will be the most powerful witches the world has ever known, they will defeat all kinds of evil. They will be known as The Charmed Ones.

Was this prophecy ever actually said on the show, I haven't seen the first episode in a while so I can't remember if it was or not. Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com 18:42, March 12, 2011 (UTC)

How come no one ever answers my questions?Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com 16:10, March 14, 2011 (UTC)

The prophecy was said by Phoebe. She and Piper were outside talking and just before Piper left for Quake, Phoebe told her that it said this in the Book of Shadows. It's in the same conversation Piper says "we have a cousin who's a drunk, an aunt who's manic, and a father who's invisible." (By the way, this is HalliwellManor) 70.64.252.74 16:20, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
Yes, but the particular prophecy above was never said nor seen in the show right?Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com 16:28, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
"Phoebe: I'm serious. She practiced powers. Three powers. She could move objects with her mind, see the future and stop time. Before Melinda was burned at the stake, she vowed that each generation of Warren witches would become stronger and stronger, culminating in the arrival of three sisters. (They walk to Piper's car.) Now, these sisters would be the most powerful witches the world has ever known. They're good witches and I think we're those sisters."
-Charmed (1x01) Something Wicca This Way Comes
No it was never seen on a page in the Book of Shadows if that's what you mean. 70.64.252.74 16:29, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
So where did that prophecy above come from?Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com 16:41, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
I think it's from the novel based on "Something Wicca This Way Comes". --PerryPeverell - (talk) - (contributions) 16:50, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
Novel? what novel? The episode aired long before the novels came out. It was simply stated in the first episode. There is no Book of Shadows entry that was ever seen containing the prophecy. 70.64.252.74 17:00, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
It's also not taken word for word from anywhere, Phoebe obviously paraphrased what she read in the Book. 70.64.252.74 17:01, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
The first novel of Charmed was based on the pilot. It may be that the particular quote used on this article comes from the novel instead of the episode. --PerryPeverell - (talk) - (contributions) 17:29, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
So is this prophecy Charmed cannon?Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com 16:26, March 15, 2011 (UTC)
On the SERIES Phoebe said she read the prophecy in the Book of Shadows. She said in the Book of Shadows, Melinda said this upon her death. THAT IS WHERE IT COMES FROM. It doesn't come from a novel or comic, it comes directly from Phoebe's mouth, as per an entry in the Book of Shadows. 216.174.136.2 16:46, March 15, 2011 (UTC)
No capitalized sentences please. This was never said on the show: You can kill me, but you cannot kill my kind. The Warren line will grow stronger with each generation, culminating in the arrival of three sisters. They will be the most powerful witches the world has ever known, they will defeat all kinds of evil. They will be known as The Charmed Ones. So I thought it might have been from the novel based on SWTWC. Someone who has that novel should check it. --PerryPeverell - (talk) - (contributions) 17:32, March 15, 2011 (UTC)

@216, Why are you yelling?
Anyway, my point is that that particular prophecy above is not cannon is it? It's never seen nor heard on the show, it is in the first novel though. But is that novel cannon as well because I believe in the book an image of Melinda Warren actually appears to Phoebe.Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com


You are wrong PerryPeverell. The quote was certainly said on the show. On the first episode right after the scene in the attic where Prue comes in and tells them the Book of Shadows is a book of witchcraft AND just before the scene with Prue at the Museum of Natural History with Roger. The script for it is right here, someone just removed the part where Piper interrupts and put the entire quote together. What Phoebe said is underlined.

[Scene: Outside Halliwell manor. Phoebe's sitting on the stairs drinking coffee. Piper comes out.]

Piper: You're up early.

Phoebe: I never went to sleep.

Piper: Don't tell me you put on a black conical hat and spent the night flying around the neighbourhood on a broomstick?

(She sits down next to Phoebe.)

Phoebe: The only broom I've ever had was kept in a closet beside a mop.

Piper: So what were you doing?

Phoebe: Reading. Is Prue around?

Piper: She went to work early. Reading aloud?

Phoebe: No. According to the Book Of Shadows, one of our ancestors was a witch, named Melinda Warren.

Piper: And we have a cousin who's a drunk, an aunt who's manic, and a father who's invisible. (She stands up.)

Phoebe: I'm serious. She practiced powers. Three powers. She could move objects with her mind, see the future and stop time. Before Melinda was burned at the stake, she vowed that each generation of Warren witches would become stronger and stronger, culminating in the arrival of three sisters. (They walk to Piper's car.) Now, these sisters would be the most powerful witches the world has ever known. They're good witches and I think we're those sisters.

Piper: Look, I know what happened last night was weird and unexplainable, but we're not witches and we do not have special powers besides, Grams wasn't a witch and as far as we know, neither was mum. (Piper kisses her on the cheek.) So take that Nancy Drew. (She gets in her car.)

Phoebe: We're the protectors of the innocent. We're known as the charmed ones. (Piper drives off.)

[Scene: The Museum of Natural History.] -- 216.174.136.2 00:53, March 17, 2011 (UTC)

216, can you not see that the quote I put in bold is different from what was said on the show? I never claimed that the prophecy was not said on the show, I'm just saying that the one on here is different from the show. Just compare the prophecy from the show with the one I put in bold. --PerryPeverell - (talk) - (contributions) 05:58, March 17, 2011 (UTC)

So my question still stands; is this:

You can kill me, but you cannot kill my kind. The Warren line will grow stronger with each generation, culminating in the arrival of three sisters. They will be the most powerful witches the world has ever known, they will defeat all kinds of evil. They will be known as The Charmed Ones.

canon despite not being seen nor heard in any episode of Charmed? Thewriter92-TheTriquetracampaign.webs.com 15:07, March 17, 2011 (UTC)

The differences aren't big. The prophecy is still the same, just reworded a bit. So technically yeah, still canon. --PerryPeverell - (talk) - (contributions) 18:50, March 17, 2011 (UTC)

Telematerialization

I doubt that Prue had Telematerialization. She was shown telekinetically transferring milk into her coffee - she didn't make the milk materialize out of nowhere. Prue was only showed once doing this, including it in her powers makes it seem like it is an individual power but it's not, its just a telekinetic transference.


For Gods sake!Who put telematerialization in Paiges powers,in the Charmedones infobox...? Paige never displayed that kind of power. 85.75.114.167 09:09, April 2, 2011 (UTC)

Phoebe's Power Connection

Phoebe's power connection works for premonition, empathy and pathokinesis but not for her levitation power. I think psychic energy works better for all her powers. She is the psychic witch.Kt111 20:00, April 26, 2011 (UTC)

Their Powers

I think it's a good idea to create a page where it's tell the skills that the sisters have with their powers, like before but no the same as before; and we should put the "Future Powers" like Piper with Molecular Manipulation, Phoebe with Telepathy (as psychic power like her others) and Paige with (maybe) Combustive Orbing 186.90.208.160 16:19, June 25, 2011 (UTC)

No offense, but I really don't. I think we should stick to what we know. For example, Phoebe may be a psychic witch, but I see no reason to list every single psychic ability as a possibility. P3nathan


Ok take it easy i just a idea but thinking good about it, it's not a good idea 186.90.208.160 16:19, June 25, 2011 (UTC)

The Evil Charmed Ones

Why does not The Evil Charmed Ones have their own pages like The Good Charmed Ones.

Because The Stillman Sisters have their own pages and Patra and Pilar and Phoenix have their own pages. ------Charmednut 13.44 13 july 2011

I assume you're talking about the CO's from It's a Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World? Well, they are exactly the same as the good CO's, so they don't get their own article. It would be useless. --— PerryPeverell 12:00, July 13, 2011 (UTC)
When the charmed ones become evil, are they stronger? Because Phoebe get pyrokinesis every time and Piper got molecular inhibition when she became a warlock, and in season four first episode Paige was able to orb the man's heart, almost killing he.— Vitor (talk) 12:38, July 13, 2011 (UTC)
They will be equally strong. --— PerryPeverell 12:34, July 13, 2011 (UTC)
Thank you.— Vitor (talk) 12:38, July 13, 2011 (UTC)
Hi I was thinking how can could The Charmed Ones be called Warlocks because they didn't kill anybody or any witch in only Leo but Piper and even Paige has killed him before. "Bride and Gloom" it is soully becasue they had blinking
Charmed Guy 12.33 29 july 2011

Paige's Powers

I think it would be better to separate Paige's witch/whitelighter powers (shielding T.O and orbing) that have the connection of movement with her Whitelighter job powers (hovering, healing, etc). Paige only got those powers when she became a full whitelighter.Kt111 17:24, July 20, 2011 (UTC)

Need a better picture

Use this one as the main picture. And who locked the wiki?


http://www.glogster.com/media/5/32/79/25/32792539.jpg

Most things on here are locked due to people constantly changing the info box photo, and altered/photoshopped photo's aren't aloud in the infobox as the main photo. —LeonardoWyatt - (talk) - (contributions) 11:26, August 10, 2011 (UTC)


A lot of people would love to see a picture of the( four) sisters together. What harm would it do to add it atleast?Saraphinabytches 11:32, August 10, 2011 (UTC)
It doesn't look right, and people can tell it's altered. It's one of the rules on here, main info box photos can not be of photo's that have been altered, or something has been photo shopped in them. —LeonardoWyatt - (talk) - (contributions) 12:17, August 10, 2011 (UTC)

Hypocritical Actions

I think that Paige and Phoebe are actually hypocritical about magic they both preach a lot about rules and personal gain but they also break the rules.

Paige use magic to have sex for stress relief and breaking her own principles

she made that big speech that she can't force Mitchell Haines to be a witch, But first she faked crashed a car and the second time she used guilt because she was stubborn and she did had big fear that she would fail like those whitelighters that had lost. She did to him what The Elders did to her about keeping Magic School open and to become a Whitelighter.

Phoebe misused her two important powers to find her future husband to the point that The Tribunal took those powers away until she earns them back.

I can't count Piper in because she has stated that she doesn't like magic and that magic is not a burden, it is a gift which she would with a douth exchange for a normal life. and she rarely uses for personal gain. I am not bashing on Charmed I just stating facts

14:15 22 august 2011------------Michelle

Piper uses her powers for personal gain as well, especially in earlier seasons when she froze people that annoyed her and froze Leo for sexual pleasure. You may hate Christy, but she was right on a certain level and the sisters themselves recognized that. Also Phoebe was punished for her misuse of powers in season 6. About Paige, I think whitelighters are allowed to go out of their way to help their charges, even if it takes some drastic measures.


I think the sisters' personal gain actions weren't that bad that they had to be punished, except for Phoebe when she used her power to find a husband. --— PerryPeverell 19:18, August 22, 2011 (UTC)
That is why I said rarely. I can admit that when she froze people that annoyed her and those who were touching her pregnant belly. And how she was blowning up Leo.

But I don't agree with you about that Piper froze Leo for sexual pleasure she said that it was a while ago and she did state that she didn't mean to freeze him it just happen,

I don't think she finds pleasure when a frozen stature is "hugging her" just like when Paige orbed by mistake when she was having sex in (Witches In Tights) . And if you are called "takes some drastic measures" by lying and manipulating no wonder The Elders are not really that popular especially with Piper.

Paige would never exist in Charmedverse if Shannen Doherty wasn't fired / quit on Charmed. And they shouldn't talk much about rules and responsibilities they faked their deaths once to get out of that. 14:16 23 august 2011------------Michelle

Piper has frozen Leo in bed more then once, Leo said this much in 'Blinded by the Whitelighter' in season 3. He siad he was okay with Piper freezing him in bed after she froze Natalie.

Extra Information

It should be noted that if they-the Charmed Ones- were to steal power, like Phoebe did in Witch Wars, that they-the powers- will become more powerful than the demon or person they gained them from, and advance. This would prove why so many warlock want there magic.

Proof (because i know how much you guys love proof): When Phoebe gail the demonic hostess powers she was able to shimmer more faster than other demons, it was more like blinking -which was stated somewhere in season 4 with Cole's assistant about she can shimmer a mile in 3 second or something like that- and her energy balls were extremely lethal than other demons and she could generate them more quickly and effortlessly- meaning she didnt have to make them grow or form and she didnt even have to throw them because if you notice other demons they form them then throw them Phoebe just shoot them like bullets - and im sure she managed to kill many upper level demons with it, it dout the bar was full of low level drunks. And I believe that the Hallow had nothing to do with the advance electrokinesis i think that it was them on there on because Billie and Christy powers didn't look all that advanced when they shoot fire or it wouldv'e been blue right like Phoebe's and the unborn source.Eric Jenkins 21:24, September 27, 2011 (UTC)

They can use the powers more quickly, true, but more powerful? I'm not sure. Most of the examples that you mentioned are not really proof. You're basing yourself on the effects. The Hollow did indeed make the sisters and Billie and Christy more powerful. The fire-effect just looked different. The same goes for the shimmering and energy balls. -- PerryPeverell 12:57, September 28, 2011 (UTC)
Okay thanks for the clarification, yeah it may have been the graphics.

Mortal Hybrids

I was thinking shouldn't it be added that The Charmed Ones are also some part mortals to, not just witches and Whitelighters etc. Because Allen Halliwell was a mortal and Penny Halliwell was human, Because every ever Human Hybrids are always represented as half-humans and never as half-mortals.

  • Mortal: human without magical abilities.
  • Human: beings that are distinguished from animals and magical beings.

CharmedGuy 14:13 October 4 2011

No, the Charmed Ones are pure witches. The magical gene, so to speak, is dormant and therefore a witch born from a mortal is a full witch, not half-mortal. If we start to label the sisters as half-mortal, then Paige, Wyatt and Chris suddenly become half whitelighter, quarter witch and quarter mortal and so on. A witch is a witch, nothing more and nothing less.

Thanks for telling me because I was always so confused about that. Because The Warren / Halliwell gene pool is kinda odd now. with half this and hybrid that. It makes my head hurt.

CharmedGuy 15:29 October 4 2011

Special Treatment

Why does The Charmed Ones get special treatment? Is it because the novels and books and TV show was written to make it so? Because otherwise it is a huge slap in the face to the rest of the magical community. And you may hate Christy, but she was right on a certain level. I think all that special treatment made The Charmed Ones feel free to use their powers for personal gain actions now and then. Charmed Guy 13:05, October 7, 2011

I do partly agree, they were a lot more driven by their own desires rather than protecting the innocent. In some ways I think it was good that Phoebe had her powers stripped in season 6, despite the fact that I think Piper and Paige were just as guilty of using their powers for personal gain as Phoebe was, I think it showed that they were still consequences for it. P3nathan

I also agree on some points. The Charmed Ones definitely grew more selfish in later season, thinking they deserved special treatment because they save the world every week. The whole personal gain thing was completely forgotten in later seasons, and aside from Phoebe losing her powers, the sisters never had to deal with the consequenses. Christy did have a valid point on some level, in her own twisted way. Charmdozo 11:37, October 7, 2011 (UTC)

And other thing they have both broken The Wiccan Rede now and then and got away with it? What the h*ll? for example in episode Hyde School Reunion when they glamoured Rick Gittridge into Chris Halliwell.I know he was a murder and wanted to kill Phoebe and Paige and he kidnapped that woman and so on but still he was a mortal also a innocent within The Wiccan Rede. And Paige just said "You know you had to? I love Charmed I really do, but sometimes really What the h*ll? Since when are they allowed to choose which innocents to save and which to let them die? Charmed Guy 13:41, October 7, 2011

I must admit, I hated that too. Phoebe: "Our job is to protect the innocent, not punish the guilty" - Morality Bites... guess that was forgotten P3nathan

I am confused now it says in It's a Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World, Part 1

Gideon: Precisely. You see, it’s all part of the grand design. A universe destined to maintain balance. Light and dark, yin and yang, good and evil. For good to prevail in this world, then an equally evil world must also exist.

Paige: Well, that’s quite a faulty design, isn’t it?

Gideon: No, it’s not Paige. Balance is everything. Without it, the cosmos doesn’t spin.

So when The Good Charmed Ones definitely grew more selfish did The Evil Charmed Ones definitely grew more good? Charmed Guy 14:03, October 7, 2011

They must have, the two worlds are supposed to be absolute opposites P3nathan

I would love to see Good Darklighter Paige, I can't even think about that and not start to smile

Innocent : Darklighter! Run!

Darklighter Paige : Yeah I am a Darklighter but I am actually trying to save your sorry excuse of life.

Charmed Guy 14:32, October 7, 2011

No wonder The Charmed Ones didn't like Natalie 'Blinded by the Whitelighter' in season 3.Because she refused to play alone with the special treatment. Charmed Guy 15:05, October 7, 2011

I think it made no sense that Phoebe got her powers stripped since a few scenes before she admitted that she misused them and was going to stop. Paige and Piper use their powers for personal gain and nothing ever happens to them. Is it because her Premonition power is passive and more valuable than other powers. And if she only abused her Premonitions why take away her Levitation and Empathy that because of her status as a Charmed One and the fact that she was constantly fighting demons were needed.Kt111 18:08, October 7, 2011 (UTC)

As far a Phoebe's punishment goes, I understand the backstage reason, but they could've done it better. I mean seriously, how many times has Piper frozen a room when she's stressed? How many times has Paige orbed an object that she could easily pick up? At least with Phoebe's premonition, the exposure risk is minimal. It didn't really ring true to me. As for Hyde School Reunion, it did annoy me, because like I said: "Our job is to protect the innocent, not punish the guilty"... so much for that! Plus I felt it was really unnecessary. Paige could have easily orbed the gun away from him P3nathan

I was wondering if the consequences of personal gain and the wiccan red would got The Charmed Ones really effectived how it was said on Charmed about evil witches and warlocks. Wouldn't The Charmed Ones turned into evil witches or warlocks long time ago by them self. Charmed Guy 13:14, October 10, 2011


for me, the charmed ones do deserve get their special treatment because they are the most powerful witches in the world, and they are recognized and the demons will always go up against them, unlike other witches, like Billie, she just hunting demons, not demons hunting them. those demons always almost screw up their normal lifes, i mean how many times the sisters will come up a good explanation with their weird behavior? those other witches, even patty and penny, they can just stop hunting demons and live on with their normal lifes, unlike charmed ones, they try very hard to maintain their normal lives. i think they deserve to get special treatments, like orbing or something, just to save the innocent quickly, how many times if the charmed ones choose not to orb, and the situation will probably gets worse? or their magical duties also screw up their dates, for me, they save the world every other week unlike other witches, they DO deserve special treatments.Vincehalliwell 09:53, February 4, 2012 (UTC)

Infobox picture!

Hi everyone :) I had some free time so I played little on photoshop :). Anyway I made a pic for the infobox. Would you like this new pic to be in infobox? Or should the old one remain?

Charmed wiki

Sky89 17:19, October 24, 2011 (UTC)

It's a nice picture, but it's too fan-made to be used as an infobox picture, at least in my opinion. It can be added to the pages' gallery though. --Piperfan7 18:11, October 24, 2011 (UTC)
You might want to check my re-write (which is kind off on a hold right now) but I have another picture, which I think is really good. I plan on finishing the re-write, though I'm not sure when. -- PerryPeverell 18:17, October 24, 2011 (UTC)The re-write is looking great, nice job and I like the pic P3nathan
I like the pic Sky89. A pic with all four sisters is better than with just the three. I know the four haven't shot a pic together but if a picture can be photoshopped well enough, it should be used. I like the triquetra included but maybe never mind the writing on the pic. 69.11.19.124 18:37, October 24, 2011 (UTC)
No matter, I just thought to trew this out there and see what happenes. I love the rewrite btv, and the pic you chosed is great. But I really want Prue to be in the pic to :D Sky89 19:20, October 24, 2011 (UTC)
The picture PerryPeverell has in the re-write doesnt show Paige.Only Prue,Piper and Phoebe. 85.75.96.94 20:33, October 24, 2011 (UTC)
Sorry :) I meant Paige :D Sky89 06:44, October 25, 2011 (UTC)
CharmedOnes
Hey guys, what's up? I made this picture, what do you think of it? Do you think it's good enough to change the infobox's one? -LoosedAngelººSummon MeººMy Spells 00:54, June 10, 2012 (UTC)







Power connections

Hi i changed to wicca power connection given that because of Paige's whitelighter side there's no real connection with her powers. Besides only the witch side has the requirement of a connection between power advancements.Kt111 04:19, December 28, 2011 (UTC)

Paige connection should be manipulation of orb, because if you guys havent noticed all of her power revolve around orbs, weither thay are witches or whitelighters. And it would make her and Prue unique.Eric Jenkins 23:48, December 29, 2011 (UTC)

It could be light and orbs since that would include healing but what is the connection with sensing and omnilingualism.Kt111 00:12, January 12, 2012 (UTC)

The link between Paige's witch powers is telekinetic energy/power of the mind... her whitelighter side doesn't have the same rules. A whitelighter is given a set of powers that are required to help charges, there isn't really much more of a connection than that. All her witch/hybrid powers however have a telekinetic aspect P3nathan

But because Paige is Charmed, she was given the powers she learned them, so their has to be some connection and it possible orbs control.68.48.156.152 02:45, January 12, 2012 (UTC)

The link is that they are whitelighter powers. Yes, Paige learned them over time as opposed to dying and getting them all at once like we can assume a normal whitelighter would, but the powers are the same and there is no apparant connection other than the fact that they are a set of powers that all whitelighters have. There are many of her whitelighter powers that don't incorperate orbs. Her hybrid powers on the other hand, both have a telekinetic aspect that incorperates orbs. P3nathan

Old Infobox

I like the old infobox including their warren powers and other powers and other things. It was very helpful and I really liked it. Why did they have to change? It may have been a little long, but not that much long. It should be changed back to the old one. Kevin Kevster 23:50, January 11, 2012 (UTC)Kevin Kevster

power and abilities

I think the "Power and Abilities" section should describe the Charmed Ones's power like Neena; described with all the things they're able to do with the "Power of Three" and with other beings like "The Avatars" CharmJonas 20:24, January 16, 2012 (UTC)

What powers are you referring to exactly? Because most of the things the power of three can do are through use of Power of Three spells, which wouldn't make them powers P3nathan

Nevermind :) CharmJonas 16:51, February 21, 2012 (UTC)

Who's Your Favorite Witch?

Who do you guys think is better? I love Prue because she is the strongest one out of all the Charmed Ones and I found her funny, mostly in season 3. I also like Piper so she comes second. I love her sarcasm and shes cute, just like Prue. Paige comes next because shes also funny but sometimes I don't like her because she seemed like an replacement of Prue and like I said I love Prue. Phoebe comes last because I believe she's the weakest one and annoys me sometimes. But that is my opinion.


(24.61.209.15 01:40, April 27, 2012 (UTC))

Tie between Prue and Phoebe, second Piper and last Paige she was overly dramatic at times.Kt111 02:10, April 27, 2012 (UTC)

I love all four sisters equally. I don't pick and choose when it comes to them. FANaticyeah 06:11, April 27, 2012 (UTC)

Piper's always been my number one, but then I grow through stages of liking Phoebe more than Paige, Paige more than Phoebe P3nathan

Prue vs Paige's years

which years do you guys like better Prue's or Paige's years? I personally love Prue's years. Oh and explain why you like it also.

I loved the Prue years too. She was awesome, and everytime i see an episode with her, it gives me the pride and confidence that she had. I just have this thing where i get so attached to characters on any show that they don't use as often as they should, but Prue had power, and i would've loved to have seen what her powers would've grown into. I wish the comics would get printed faster than they've been doing b/c i love that they're showing Prue again, especially in the upcoming comics. Paige was still pretty cool, but she seemed to have had some limits to her powers, and also very vulnerable to darklighters.

I've always found them kind of hard to compare since Paige was on for 5 years and Prue only had 3. I like certain aspects of both. I like the darker tone of the Prue years, but I like the bigger scale storylines they had in the Paige years (Avatars, Bad Bad Bad World etc), although I would've hoped they would still have done stuff like that if Prue had stayed. I also like Piper being more of a focus after Prue is gone, since she's my favourite. But then I didn't really like the fixation on very light storylines they had in season 5 and parts of season 6... not to say they were bad seasons overall, because I did enjoy them as a whole, I just preferred the darker tone in the Prue years (hence seasons 4 and 7 being my fav Paige seasons, since they're much darker than 5 and 6) P3nathan

I liked the Prue years but i would have liked to see Piper and Phoebe's powers develop around the darker tone of the Prue years and see the different effect given to empathy since i doubt they woul have used that jingling. I also like the fact that the storylines were never focused on one sister. The show was about three sisters and it should have stayed that way. The Paige years focus was around Piper. Paige and Phoebe had little character growth always centering their storylines around guest love interest that had no future and later rushing to find them husbands when the show was about to end.Kt111 15:31, April 29, 2012 (UTC)

Not sure, I agree with that focus bit... Prue was central a lot in the first 2 seasons whereas the Phoebe and Cole story was the main focus of season 3. Sure there were sub plots about the other sisters' love lives, jobs etc... but there were in seasons 4-8 too. I'd also argue that seasons 4 and 5 were very Phoebe centric, again due to the Phoebe-Cole story. Although I do completely agree with you on how they treated Phoebe's character in the later seasons P3nathan

I liked prue years because like P3nathan it was dark and it also had some funny moments and at the end of each of episodes, it shows the sisters all together smiling and having fun. In paige's years there were always suspense at the end of each episode and it was more of a comedy then a drama-supernatural show.

Who do you think Had the Best Sister Relationship

Which sister relationship did you like better? Prue and Piper, Prue and Phoebe, Prue and Paige(in season 9), Piper and Phoebe, Piper and Paige, Paige and Phoebe.

(24.61.209.15 19:12, May 11, 2012 (UTC))

Even though they had their fights i like Prue and Phoebe's relationship I think they were a lot a like and that was the focus of most of their fights. During season 2 and 3 because of all the relationship drama Piper was going through they relied on eachother a lot at that time. lt was Prue who comforted Phoebe about her past life and then it was Phoebe who helped Prue out with the solo demon hunting. One of my favorite episodes was The Power of Two particularly how the episode started with them at odds and by the end they banded together having developed a new understanding and appreciation of eachother. I also like the Phoebe/Piper, Piper/Prue, Phoebe/Paige and Piper/Paige relationships in that order.Kt111 21:29, May 11, 2012 (UTC)

You forgot Prue/Paige sister relationship in season 9. Prue was there for Paige and told her not to not strip her powers. Instead of Paige stripping her powers, Prue stripped hers. Anyways my favorite sister relationship will have to be Prue/Piper because they were always there for each other and you can tell they were way closer then Phoebe and Paige. Especially in Coyote Piper when Piper was dying, she only called Prue and not Phoebe. Also in Coyote Piper, Prue was there to defend and stick up for Piper. Then after Prue's death, you see how Piper dealt with that.

(24.61.209.15 03:39, June 24, 2012 (UTC))

Do you guys agree?

Do you guys agree that seasons 4-8, Piper had the most storylines then Phoebe or Paige. Like when Prue died, only Piper broke down and cry not even Phoebe cried over her sister's death. Then in season 5 it mostly seemed like that whole season was about Piper and her dealing with her first child and pregnancy. Then in seaosn 6 it about Piper and Leo's relationship and their son Chris. Then in season 7 it was about Piper dealing with her second child and pregnancy and then in season 8 it was about Piper losing then getting back Leo and the last episode was about her losing and getting back her younger sisters Phoebe and Paige. Only Phoebe and Paige have to deal with is their relationships and they only had like 1 big storyline and thats it. Like I felt that the show was only about Piper.

Season 3 to the first half of Season 5 was much more Phoebe and Cole based. And yes, the later season revolved much more about Piper, but her relationship with Leo was the longest relationship any of the sisters ever had. It's only natural that the storylines are much more focused on them. And I think that both Phoebe and Paige had interesting storylines, Phoebe losing her powers, Paige becoming a Whitelighter, etc. -- PerryPeverell 20:50, May 28, 2012 (UTC)
I agree with Perry. Piper was very central a lot, yes, but it wasn't all about her all the time. For example (as he said): Seasons 3 to 5 covered the Phoebe and Cole story, which was a very large focus of those 3 seasons.I'm probably biast to be honest, because I love Piper... but Prue was central a lot during the first 3 seasons when she was the oldest, didn't mean the others didn't have storylines. Plus, people loved Piper and Leo, the writers knew this, so they were given plenty of stories P3nathan
Starting with the birth of Wyatt, everything started revolving around Piper's family instead of the three sisters. Paige and Phoebe became stuck with temporary love interests and silly or annoying plotlines like the baby quest and stupid temp jobs. it was always predictable that their love interests would never last. However, Piper is my favorite sister, so I don't always mind. Charmdozo 21:07, May 28, 2012 (UTC)
It seems to me that in seasons 1-3 there was more of a balance when it came to the girls storyline focus. In season 2 Piper had a big storyline with Dan and Leo plus opening her club, Prue had her job change and her going out into the dating world after Andy plus her new power, and Phoebe returned to school and became a super witch with her knowledge of spells and potions. Sure in season 3 Phoebe had Cole and her new power, but Prue was the super witch this time focused on her charmed life and Piper had the Leo forbidden love/wedding and losing him for a while too plus in both season 2 and 3 there was a storyline about how she wanted to lose her powers. She also got a new power in season 3. Maybe it's not so much the growing focus on Piper but the fact that her same storylines were repeated again and again for example we have seen episodes about her wanting a normal life in season 2, 3, 6 and 8 with very little difference between them and the losing Leo storyline was also used a lot.Kt111 00:12, May 29, 2012 (UTC)
I think they had a habbit of repeating stuff like that with all 3 sisters to be honest. Paige finding a calling seperate from her sisters kept coming up from season 5 onwards. Phoebe trying to find a man and get a baby started in season 6 and went right through to the final season... plus we saw her go back to college twice and her love interests were very repetitive: Jason, Leslie, Dex- she'd meet them at work, fall for them, magic would go crazy and interfere and they'd part ways not long after. P3nathan

I agree with Kt111, Piper storyline is mainly about Leo losing his power, Leo regaining his power, Piper losing Leo, Piper finding Leo, one of Piper's kids is in danger; I mean come on; her storyline is pathetic compare to Phoebe and Paige's, and not just because her storyline is never about her, it's also because the repeat the same crap over and over again.

Phoebe storyline: Evolving from a reckless young lady, focusing on her witchcraft, finding a danger/great love, becoming a famous columist, overcoming a evil pregnancy, divorcing Cole, lots more tragic love and helping her older sister protect her family, finding her true love, regaining her powers and having kids of her own; all the while being Charmed.

Paige storyline: Finding her sisters, focusing on her witchcraft, lots of love interest and temp jobs inbetween, helping her older sister protect her family, becoming a whitelighter, finding her true love and having kids of her own; all the while being Charmed.

Piper has no presence (she is just there) and most of the time comes across as a non entity to me; and it's mainly because the focus is never on her, but on the men in her life. These are just my personal views.Superlana 12:29, May 29, 2012 (UTC)

I do agree with that quite a bit actually... Although you did forget to mention Piper's evolution from the Prue years to the Paige years and how much stronger and confident she became in herself. But I agree with the Wyatt and Leo part. Everyone says it became all about Piper when Wyatt arrived, but really Wyatt was the focus, Piper started off the warrior mother but ended up simply being central by default as Wyatt grew. Although, it was said that family is everything to Piper, she was made up to be the nurturing, mother figure of the family, so it could be said that when the show was about the family, it became about Piper.
This is one thing I love about season 9: Piper has finally opened up her restaraunt, has regained her matriarchal leadership qualities (as we saw last issue) and is really becoming her own person again. I guess it helps that all three are married with kids now. P3nathan

Telepathic Connection

Well many are saying that The Charmed Ones has telepathic connection with each other now. And it says a lot on the Charmed wiki as well. Shouldn't Telepathy be added on their own respected infoboxes?? Charmednut 15:28 May 29 2012

The telepathic connection was a spell that Phoebe cast when she wanted to find Piper and Paige, so it's not a power P3nathan

And when their senses were taken away.Kt111 18:51, May 29, 2012 (UTC)

The sisters might share a psychic connection but that doesn't mean they possess telepathy. They cannot read the minds of each other except for special circumstances, and even then it's very limited, more like shared intuition than actual mind reading. They also cannot read the minds of others of broadcast their thoughts, so it's not telepathy. Charmdozo 19:08, May 29, 2012 (UTC)

I think that in abnormal ocurrences they have the possibility to connect with eachother telepathically like when Phoebe cast that power of three spell.Kt111 03:01, May 30, 2012 (UTC)

7th season should of been the series finale

Do you guys think that season 7 finale should of been the last episode instead of season 8? I think season 7 should of been because Piper and Phoebe recapped everything that had happened to them in the past 6 or 7 years, Darryl was in that season, and Prue was mentioned and she shut the door at the end of the episode which I loved (and I don't know if you guys saw it but they kinda showed Prue's face when the police officer were looking at pictures of the charmed ones). The whole season 8 was boring to me and I didn't like Billie and Christy and the end of the episode didn't show any pictures of Prue and I know its because Shannen Doherty didn't want any photos of her shown in the show but they didn't even show Prue when she was little. I don't think Shannen own that girl who played Prue when she was little photes. But I want to know you guys opinion?

I do think season 7 was way better than season 8 generally and I do love the finale....though I've heard some fans say that the end of s7 made it look like they were kind of walking away from their heritage and people didn't like that. But I'd maybe just rework that a bit, I wasn't a fan of s8, curse of the final season, many shows catch it. P3nathan

I think Billie's introcuction should have been better. Instead of a girl playing witch she should have been a strong witch demon hunter looking for her sister kind of like centenial charmed alternate Piper. If we knew her purpose from the start her new projection power and finding her sister wouldnt have felt so rushed and forced. The same thing with her turning evil.Kt111 18:13, June 14, 2012 (UTC)

The whole new indentity thing would have never worked out. Seriously, not to mention legal and financial issues, how would Piper and Leo raise their children? And I thought the Elders and demons were already pretty stupid for not realizing it right away, but they would have found out eventually. Come on, three cousins, one with a husband, move into the manor, take over the club and the kids? The only way the new indentities would have ever worked is if they had completely abandoned every single aspect of their lives. Charmdozo 21:13, June 14, 2012 (UTC)

Well I think season 7 kind of implied that that's what they were doing, having them walk away from the Manor at the end... I dunno, I think the storyline suffered quite a bit due to the WB leaving them hanging for so long before confirming whether season 8 had the go ahead or not; I imagine if they hadn't had the difficulty of creating a storyline that could end the series aswell as keep the potential for a season 8, it would've been much better. I personally would have respected Brad Kern quite a bit more if he had stood up and said "You know what? Forget messing us around like this! Season 7 is our last and that's our final decision!". Having networks have too much control really isn't a good thing most of the time... that's why I respect Joss Whedon so much for announcing that season 7 was the last Buffy whether the network wanted more or not, because it was his show and he took the control. P3nathan

Power Control

Isnt it weird that whenever the sisters transform into demons or other magical beings they have absolut control of whatever powers they develop. I'm not counting Prue's empathy because of the nature of the power and the fact that it was a spell backfire. Meanwhile whenever they receive a power advancement it's always uncontrollable at first even though they were destined to gain those powers.Kt111 21:30, June 15, 2012 (UTC)

Charmed in Death

Was Prue still a Charmed One in death or did she become charmed again when Piper and Phoebe met Paige? She told Cole in "The Heavens Can Wait" that the prophecy was tearing at her, which is why she helped her sisters find Paige, but then Cole said in "Family Shatters" that it was really Prue who refused to let go of the Po3 and not the other way around. It's kinda confusing.

Maybe Prue just considered herself a charmed one after death, but wasn't actually charmed. The season four premiere was called "Charmed Again", which lead me to think that Piper and Phoebe were no longer a part of the prophecy. It would make sense given that Prue did die suddenly and would have trouble moving on, accepting that her life was over. I don't think the Angels of Destiny would've let her move onto the afterlife if she was still truly bound to the Charmed prophecy; before Piper and Phoebe met Paige, I think Prue just considered herself to still be charmed, as opposed to actually being so. She became charmed again due to the bond she shared with her sisters.

If Prue were still a charmed one in death, she'd be what, half-Charmed, along with Piper and Phoebe? The power of three would be divided as opposed to being destroyed and Paige would only partially fix the Po3 since it was only partially broken? Paige would be half a Charmed One? I don't buy that.184.190.194.66 10:51, October 24, 2012 (UTC)Logan

I think its because of the bond she had with her sisters, and i think the reason why Prue refused to give up the Po3 was maybe because it would mean that she would lose the connection with her sisters. We always focused on Piper and Phoebe's loss of her big sister but it must have been just as hard or even more so for Prue to lose her sisters since as the oldest she spent most of her life caring for and protecting them. Another possibility is that given the sate of her relationship with both Piper and mostly Phoebe before they became charmed she associated their sisterhood with being charmed.Kt111 (talk) 00:16, October 25, 2012 (UTC)

Yeah, that makes sense as to why Prue would be reluctant to give up her Charmed destiny, but I didn't understand whether or not she was still charmed after she died. I thought since the title of the season four episode was "Charmed Again," that Piper and Phoebe were no longer charmed, at least not until Paige came into the picture. I thought she couldn't let go of her charmed destiny, not the other way around; if she was still charmed in death, before Piper and Phoebe met Paige, then Paige wouldn't be able to reconstitute the Po3 because it wouldn't be completely broken and wouldn't allow enough room for her. I don't know, dude. This is all very confusing.

How Prue described what happened when her soul returned suggested that she and Paige were sharing in the same Po3; when Paige reconstituted the Charmed Ones, Prue became charmed again as well. And since Prue was dead, her magic couldn't grow, meaning that Piper and Phoebe's magic couldn't grow either, and neither could Paige's since her magic was connected to the latter's. Prue, Piper, and Phoebe were pretty powerful, but not as powerful as prophesized; their magic was rendered static, unable to grow any further. That's why on the show it seemed, at least to me, that Piper, Phoebe, and Paige were merely powerful witches, but not the most powerful ever to the walk the earth.

It also goes along with what happened when Prue and Paige met; their powers didn't seem to escalate the way Piper and Phoebe's did. I guess it was because Piper and Phoebe's powers grew as a response to Prue and Paige sharing the same spot, like their powers doubled. Here are some numbers, each one represents a charmed one.

70 + 70 + 70 + (70) = Piper, Phoebe, and Paige, while Prue is still sharing in the power.

70 + (70)=140=Prue and Paige meeting.

70 + (70), 70 + (70)=what happens to Piper and Phoebe as a means of balancing the power out, but really just ends up dividing it.

140 + 140 + 70 + 70=Two sisters are twice as powerful as the other two are separately.184.190.194.66 04:49, October 25, 2012 (UTC)Logan

It is kind of confusing but I'll try to break it down as much as possible. The Charmed Prophecy, foretold by Melinda Warren, was intended for Prue, Piper, and Phoebe. Prophecies are written in stone. So when Prue died, she was still bound to the Prophecy, still tethered to the Power of Three and the bond with her sisters. Apparently, bonds made my magic can't even be broken in death. So yeah, you're right. Piper and Pheobe were no longer Charmed because the circle was broken so Prue had Paige come in to repair that circle and reconstitute the Power of Three as the third Halliwell sister but that still wasn't enough. SHE was still tied to them because prophecies aren't SUPPOSED to transfer to anyone; they're meant who they're meant for. And I really don't think the Angels of Destiny had control over whether she died or not. She had already moved on before anyone could do anything about it. They can cause death (like with Leo in Season 8) but I don't think they have the jurisdiction to control who goes back to the land of the living after death unless someone's being reincarnated. And you're right about one thing, Paige only partially repaired the Power of Three, but I don't think you can think of her as "half-Charmed." They were still completely Charmed, but there was just an unknown limit placed on the power of three because Prue was still tearing it apart in the afterlife by still being bound to the prophecy. 137.140.121.21 14:42, October 25, 2012 (UTC)

Yeah, I read on some other message board that people thought Paul was saying that Piper, Phoebe, and Paige were weaker than the original trio; I never thought that. They weren't weaker, but they weren't stronger either; they were about the same in power. It was because Prue was still sharing in the Po3 (in the afterlife, dead so her powers wouldn't grow) and that kept the Charmed Ones' power static, unable to grow to its full potential.

I think Prue was wrong about who exactly the prophecy was meant for; if it was meant for the three eldest sisters, thus excluding Paige, then I don't think she would've been able to repair it. The Po3 would've been completely destroyed, beyond repair. Paige was meant to become a charmed one, regardless of whether or not anyone foresaw it. It was meant for three sisters w/ three specific powers.

I think Melinda, or whatever oracle/seer/witch foresaw, was a possible future, not a fixed future. On the show, the future was changed on a regular basis (Prue's blonde and alive, Piper's first kid is a girl, Phoebe's burned at the stake, Wyatt's an evil dictator, etc). Although powerful, I don't think Melinda Warren was an infallible prophet; she just didn't foresee Paige. And when Prue was talking about the 'Power of Four' not being viable, she was really talking about the concept of the Po3; it's an ancient form of magic that can only be properly invoked with three magical beings, not four.

And the whole thing about prophecies not being SUPPOSED to transfer to anyone; I kinda think they shouldn't be ABLE to transfer. Paige is either meant to be charmed or she isn't; if the prophecy was specifically meant for Prue, then it couldn't transfer to Paige, at least not without some kind Angel of Destiny's interference.

I think what happened is what was meant to be, albeit with a few hitches. Both Prue and Paige were meant to be charmed, just not at the same time. The fact that the Po3 can go on w/o Prue is a testament to that. I'm not hating on Prue, just so you know. I just think that if something is specifically meant for one person, then it won't work w/o that one person. I think when Prue was saying all that stuff to Cole, she was speaking more out of emotion than logic and I really can't blame her for that; who would wanna think they're replaceable? I sure wouldn't.

I guess I just take issue with the notion of prophecies being transferable; I thought they were kinda fixed, impossible to alter naturally. If Paige could share in the Charmed prophecy, however much so, then it must've been meant for her as well.184.190.194.66 04:55, October 26, 2012 (UTC)Logan

Arrested

Isnt it funny that all the charmed ones at some point in their lives were arrested.Kt111 (talk) 00:20, October 25, 2012 (UTC)

Not really... Most groups with large secrets end up facing external consequences to protect those secrets. Dcoffron (talk) 02:28, October 25, 2012 (UTC)

Phoebe, Only One Born Charmed?

Was Phoebe the only one born a Charmed One? Because the Charmed Ones didn't exist at least until Phoebe's conception, as shown in "That 70's Episode." Before Phoebe was conceived/born, Prue and Piper were just regular witches, right? They possessed the potential to be Charmed, as did Paige later on.184.190.194.66 05:02, October 30, 2012 (UTC)Logan

I believe that's the correct notion. TheFanatic (talk) 05:32, October 30, 2012 (UTC)

Demon boyfriends

Its funny, but true. In Charmed Again, Part 2, Phoebe says that Paige is not one of them untill she's dated a demon. I see pattern in those boyfriends. When the Charmed Ones go stronger with age, the case of their demonic boyfriends it is the opposite: (^-means greater power)

What do you guys say?Undominanthybrid (talk) 21:48, January 12, 2013 (UTC)

A note about something similar to this is already on the Warren Witches page I believe. Charmdozo (talk) 17:13, January 24, 2013 (UTC)

I meant with emphasis to the power of the boyfriends.Undominanthybrid (talk) 18:11, January 24, 2013 (UTC)

Paige Reconstituting Charmed Ones

I don't think Paige received the power of telekinesis because it was missing; I think she already had it, otherwise how could she become a Charmed One? I don't think she would've received the power possessed by the missing sister; prophecies aren't fluid and can't be manipulated.

I don't think a being can be made to fit a prophecy; they would have to naturally be a candidate for it. I mean, her powers were obviously bound; her not being a Charmed One doesn't mean she wouldn't still be a witch with an active power.  

The author of the article could just say her powers became activated when she met her sisters.184.190.204.77 05:43, May 23, 2013 (UTC)Logan

Charmed Prophecy

So in "The Heavens Can Wait", Prue stated the charmed prophecy wouldn't let her move on, it wouldn't let go of her, but in reality it was she who couldn't let go of it, because she felt she'd be losing her sisters, right? If the prophecy was still in effect after Prue's death (before Paige entered the picture), then Paige wouldn't be able to reconstitute the Charmed Ones, right?

Show Better Off W/ Shannen's Departure?

Don't mean to offend any Prue fans, but I just think the show was better off with Shannen leaving. I don't think we would've gotten a chance to see Piper's amazing character development, going from meek and shy to assertive and strong-willed; though I guess we saw hints of that in S2 and later in S3.

I don't think we would've seen Piper's character grow to the extent that it did if Prue hadn't died, as circumstances forced her to take up that role. I also think that the show became more of what it was supposed to be, the focus being on three sisters instead of one woman (Prue) with her sisters as supporting characters. Just my opinion of course.

I liked Paige and her arrival, but I do wish the show had retained some of that darkness it had in the seasons beforehand. Though I do wonder if seasons 4 through 8 would've been the same tone-wise, even if Shannen hadn't left.184.190.204.77 15:51, June 15, 2013 (UTC)Logan

Similarity in powers

Does anyone else notice the similarity with the charmed ones powers. Like Telekinetic Levitation and Levitation, ATK and MC, ATKO and MC, MC and TK, Sensing and Premonition based Enhanced Intuition, Sensing and Empathy. I just miss the days when the sisters personalities and powers were made to be very distinctive. Granted it's obvious that they should develop their personalities and powers for better overall character evolution but I do still miss it.Kt111 (talk) 15:02, July 1, 2013 (UTC)

Extra Power Boost

Now that Prue has a new different destiny, does this mean that the Charmedones could get some power boost....??Because as Prue said she was the reason they couldnt reach the full potention of the Power Of Three was because of her being still attached to their Charmed deastiny even after her death.Now that she has moved on, she is not holding them back.That means that Piper, Phoebe and Paige could get some new powers or increase the ones they have.What to you think....?? 94.71.201.134 17:42, October 6, 2013 (UTC)

Paige: Sibling or Half-sister....??

Paiges  status as sibling of Piper,Phoebe and Prue doesnt seem right.

They are sisters, however they all do not come from the same parents.

Paige is the daughter of Patty and Sam.

The other three girls are the daughters of Patty and Victor.

They have only one parent in common, their mother.

So I think its more suitable if we add "half-sister" next to Paiges name in the Charmedones infoboxes, because she is a sibling but also she is a half-sister.

What do you think....?? 94.71.159.55 21:22, October 7, 2013 (UTC) 

Power Usage

Piper Vs. Phoebe and Paige 

Did anyone else notice that Piper used her  powers way more than Phoebe and Paige did (Im not counting Prue because she was only present for three seasons) everytime something happend such as a deamon coming in Piper would freeze or blow something up. I havent seen an episode from about Season 3 onwards (i havent seen season 1-2 in full) where Piper hasnt used one of her powers. Phoebe rarely used her Levitation power though she did have it only for a limited amount of time and Paige didnt really use her TK Orbing power to full advantage so we never got to see it evolve like we could have. Any Thoughts Cirino 73 (talk) 12:57, November 19, 2013 (UTC)

That's because Piper had the main offensive power. In seasons 1-3, the main battle move would be for Prue to send the demon flying; in seasons 4-8 it would be for Piper to blast them. Although I do agree that there was a far better balance in power usage in the first 3 seasons. I didn't think season 4 was too bad with the balance, but then starting from season 5: Freezing, Premonition, and Levitation seemed to be used less and less. P3nathan (talk)


             

Born Charmed?

The sisters' status as the Charmed Ones refers to the Power of Three, right? They're only charmed as long as the Po3 is intact, correct?

Or were they all born charmed, individually, and they just formed the Po3? Like Prue and Piper were charmed before Phoebe was conceived and Piper and Phoebe were charmed after Prue died; and Paige was charmed, just not a member of the Po3?

This is a bit confusing, since I always thought that their charmed-status rested upon the fact that there was three of them with three specific powers.174.64.173.18 20:15, September 2, 2014 (UTC)Rick

Paige's Power Activation

I'd like to point that Paige's powers being activated wouldn't result in her having Prue's power simply because it was missing; she must've already had it. I request that the piece of the article that states Paige merely received the power because it was missing be changed because it's inaccurate and there's no basis for it. Joining her sister wouldn't haven given her the power to move things with her mind; it would've unlocked any latent powers she had, since Phoebe cast the spell to unbind the Charmed Ones' powers in the pilot, but it wouldn't have given her any powers.

The fact that the sisters retained their powers outside of the Power of Three just further proves my point that Paige didn't need to be a Charmed One in order to have a power; she did need a power to have Charmed-potential, as that was required in order to create the Power of Three.

Melinda just foresaw the first three sisters being Charmed Ones with specific powers; she foretold what would happen. She observed it. That observation wouldn't have any bearing on whether or not Paige had any powers. The Power of Three was already formed, so what? They didn't need the Po3 in order to have their individual powers.

The article should just state that Paige's powers were unbound and she displayed the power of telekinesis, like Prue.CharmedBoy19802 (talk) 19:21, September 9, 2014 (UTC)CharmedBoy

Prophecy : The Most Powerful Witch/es

So.. how reliable is this prohecy?

First, there sisters (Charmed Ones) -the eldest who moves things with her mind, the middle who freezes time, and the youngest who sees into the past, present, and future- were prophesied to be greatest witches of all times.

But then, 'three sisters' (Reconstituted Charmed Ones)-the eldest who freezes time AND blows thing up, the middle who sees into the past, present, and future AND levitates, and the youngest who orbs- were prophesied to be greatest witches of all times.

And also, a twice-blessed child (Wyatt) was prophesied to be the greatest witch of all times.

Not to mention that, two sisters (Ultimate Power) were prophesied to be the greatest witches all of times.

On the meantime, Neena the first and the most powerful witch was already alive in all these times.

How can there be five group of most powerful witch/es prophesied or actually exist in the same timeline? Avatar Tin (talk) 17:26, January 15, 2016 (UTC)

I think the prophecy stated that the Charmed Ones would be the most powerful witches of all time. It just turned out that Melinda didn't see all the Charmed Ones. Did the prophecy ever state which sister had which powers? I remember Phoebe deducing who had which power in the pilot. I think it just said that there would be three sister witches descended from Melinda Warren, each possessing one of her powers. I could be wrong, though. Well, anyway, I think Wyatt was just stated to be an incredibly powerful being, as were Billie and Christy.

Neena's a powerful witch, but certainly not the most powerful, otherwise she wouldn't have needed the Charmed Ones' help in vanquishing the Source.70.189.34.150 08:09, January 17, 2016 (UTC)FanaticallyCharmed

Phobe's Active powers

Stop tAking Remote beaming of of Phobe's Active powers as when u look at her other dauters page it says it's and active power so Phobe should be able to keep it as an active power for her section of the charmed ones powers

Remember to sign your posts. It is not added because it is not one of her "main" powers. Her beaming is limited to Coop only, it only exists because of her connection to Coop and has nothing to do with being a witch/charmed one. Charmdozo (talk) 19:19, April 4, 2016 (UTC)

Power Connection

Can we remove Mind from Prue and Paige's power connection section considering all the sisters have the mind as a connection of their powers. Example: Piper can mentally speed up molecules in objects or Phoebe can see the future using her mind. Movement seems like a more logical power connection that works for Prue and Paige. In that sense shouldnt psychic energy or something of the sort be a better power connection for Phoebe since it includes all of Phoebe's powers and not just premonition and empathy like seeing and feeling does.Kt111 (talk) 03:47, August 28, 2016 (UTC)

Go ahead and make the changes. I agree mind is too general. Charmdozo (talk) 08:46, August 28, 2016 (UTC)

Abilities

I think it needed to added under Powers and Abilities, subcategory Abilities, that after years of demon fighting they all developed a serious hand to hand combat skills.