Talk:Phoebe Halliwell

From Charmed

Contents 1 Phoebe at the stake 2 Predisposition to Evil 3 Powers section of infobox 4 Opening Paragraph 5 Name Spelling 6 Morality Bites 7 Powers from the Womb 8 Wrong or Not ?

[edit] Phoebe at the stake

Quick question, I wonder if anybody else can tell me. In the episode Morality Bites, when Phoebe was at the stake, she was certainly about to die but did she actually die ? If not the information should be removed as it says on her page she does die. --2Anthony4 (talk)17:38, 16 November 2008 (UTC)

You can remove the info. She did not die, she was sent back before she had a chance to. --Leoandpiper Talk Contribs 17:51, 16 November 2008 (UTC)

Future Phoebe did die until the moment where the sisters learn that they can't punish. So I think it can stay on her page. TheCharmedFreak | talk | contributions 07:32, 17 November 2008 (UTC)

But do you hve any prrof she died ? She was about too but did they say that she did die ? I think they only said she was going to. --2Anthony4 (talk)20:21, 18 November 2008 (UTC)

Future Phoebe was still burning on the stake (and probably died) until the moment that they realized their mistake (after being send back) They didn't say it but it's true. The whole future changed when Phoebe said to Piper and Prue that they are not meant to punish. TheCharmedFreak | talk | contributions 13:11, 19 November 2008 (UTC)

Basically no, she did not die at all, She even said during the episode (when they were returned to the past):

Phoebe: I could feel the flames lick my skin, but I couldn't die

She would've died though if the Charmed Ones hadn't realised the whole personal gain thing. Howevr there are many tmes when the Charmed Ones have been mortally wounded and were going to die but didn't. Mortal wounds aren't put n the death counts so neither should this as they're both on par with each other.

[edit] Predisposition to Evil

Why was my piece on Phoebe's Predisposition to Evil removed? Hjordis 17:55, 23 November 2008 (UTC)

Oh sorry, I thought I left a note on your page! The information you inputed was good, but it was speculation. You can add a few sentences under notes but that much info shouldn't have been added. You can add it into the power section as well if you wish and please feel free to add it to your user page. Sorry, I don't want to sound like one of those controlling admins! :) --Leoandpiper Talk Contribs 18:49, 23 November 2008 (UTC)

OK, I completely understand. You're not being controlling at all! I'll definitely add in some info under notes. Hjordis 20:14, 23 November 2008 (UTC)

[edit] Powers section of infobox

Does anyone think Pheobes (and maybe the rest her sisters) power section of the infobox should be edited to powers and abilities, so that it also includes her Kickboxing and Martial Arts. I believe that it was from the jumps, leaps and agility of her fighting skills that caused her to develop the power of Levitation. It does seem imporant to mention but what does anyone else think?

Personally no. Thats what the powers and abilities section is for However if everyone was to say yes there are the following problems:

1) We'd have to actually make a new template for it otherwise it wouldn't show up properly (I think)

2) We'd have to change every other characters box to that on the wikia. And I'm sure as hell not gonna bother with that.

Anyone else? Wiccid 20:01, 27 April 2009 (UTC)

[edit] Opening Paragraph

Is all that information necessary in the opening paragraph? it is later presented in the below paragraphs of the article and just sounds repetative and redundant.--HalliwellManorAkaDsc385 15:24, 13 May 2009 (UTC)

[edit] Name Spelling

In A Witch's Tail Part 2, when Phoebe signs the divorce papers she signs "Pheobe Halliwell" not "Phoebe Halliwell". Was her name ever shown as Phoebe on the series? I don't recall.

It's a little mistake by Alyssa Milano. Phoebe is spelled Phoebe not Pheobe. Her name is seen many times, remember "Ask Phoebe" ?? So just a little blooper. TheBook 09:23, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

I just had a moment of memory loss, of course.--HalliwellManorAkaDsc385 15:16, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

[edit] Morality Bites

When did Phoebe say she could "feel the flames lick her skin" and she couldn't die? she said " I don't know. All I know is I could feel it, I could feel the fire."

Then when she was about to be burned, Piper froze the rooms and Phoebe told them "The wrong thing done for the right reason is still the wrong thing. Our job is to protect the innocent, not punish the guilty. And I crossed that line, I know that. And now you guys have to know that too". "Prue, we were sent here for a reason. Maybe not to stop this like we thought. But maybe to understand why this has to happen. Why you have to let this happen. I don't want to die. But I don't want you to die because of me."

After they returned to the present she said "I was burned. And I could, I could feel the flames on my skin. And then I was here. I don't know what happened."

And she later stated while discussing Pratt at the end of the episode, "Apparently neither have we. I think this is why we were sent back here to this moment in time. This is where it all started. The first time we used our magic for revenge."

--HalliwellManorAkaDsc385 06:34, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

[edit] Powers from the Womb

Patty had a premonition when she was pregnant with Phoebe, yet when Phoebe was pregnant with the Source, Piper says that unborn babies don't have powers from the womb (unless of course they're super powerful like the Source or Wyatt). In another episode, Chris was also completely appalled when he learns that Wyatt had powers from the womb. Could this mean anything or is it just a mistake? Jules R. J. Blake 13:53, 13 August 2009 (UTC)

Piper didn't know that Patty had a premonition and she had Wyatt after she said it. She didn't know it was possible. Having powers from the womb can just be like adolescence, you either start early or late which could be the reason that Chris didn't have powers from the womb. --TheBook 17:49, 13 August 2009 (UTC)

[edit] Wrong or Not ?

I think there may be a problem, correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe it was Piper not Phoebe that was turned into the 1950's house wife by Grams' cursed wedding ring. Also I thought when Chris wished Phoebe to make Piper and Leo to sleep together they fell on the couch not the floor. Not 100% on that, but I really thought so unless I missed the part that they picked them off the floor idk maybe I need to review that again, but in the meantime if you know for sure please let me know. As far as grams ring I remember Piper was in the attic searching in the Book of Shadows when she happened to look down at her finger as the ring appeared on her finger then she transformed into the 1950's house wife and she then took off to go clean and cook, so I believe that Phoebe's page is wrong about it being her that it happened to. Please let me know for sure if you think I may be wrong. Dena.morgin9 05:40, 23 August 2009 (UTC)

Hi Dena.morgin9,

It's true that Piper turned into a 1950's housewife in season 8 but Phoebe turned in one as well in season 4, Lost and Bound. And when Chris wished for Piper and Leo to sleep together, Piper and Leo were still in the conservatory so they fell on the ground and were then put on the couch.

So Phoebe's article is not wrong :) --TheBook 12:02, 23 August 2009 (UTC)