Sally was disappointed of Billy's loyalty when he returned to the movie with three women. After Billy, Phoebe and Piper entered the movie, Prue was attacked by a Film Geek while the others fought the Demon of Illusion; Sally Mae helped out with a tree branch. She and Billy were seen again at the end.
Two years later, Phoebe lost her hearing and tested it by watching the movie; only Sally Mae appeared this time.
Sally Mae appeared in a total of 3 episodes over the course of the series.
- Season 2
- Chick Flick
- Season 3
- Bride and Gloom
- Season 5
- Sense and Sense Ability