Because it never really stated that they were immortal, even Leo never said that. He said they die and then are reborn as empaths, like a cycle. and reincarnation doesn't count as immortality, because that means they never die of natural causes. What Father Thomas said sounds alot more like epiphany and philosophy based on what he's experienced from his gift than a statement of empaths being immortal. wouldn't we have known that otherwise?
Look, a few years ago, someone speculated that Grams had astral projection all because she and Prue had telekinesis when she clearly never showed that power. so, unless we know FOR SURE that empaths are immortal, I think we should leave that part out.
I doubt you can compare them to whitelighters. they're humans who die with loads of good deeds in their lifetimes and are then rewarded with becoming angels, empaths seem different to me. did Leo ever say that they were immortal? like non-dying immortal rather than reincarnating?
All the important relationships already heave pages. The other relationships are not important enough. Besides, creating new pages for all the other relationships will only repeat info already on other pages.
sorry Charmdozo but i don't agree with you. I think that we need all this relationships pages. I think they're very interesting, and not only the romantic relationships but also the ones between the sisters. A lot of wiki are making pages like that, the smallville's wiki being a really good example :) i think Charmed-Jay should be doing them if he wants to.
Well, first of all, what other wiki's do is completely irrelevant here. Each wiki is different.
Secondly, in the entire time I have been editing here, I have never heard anyone ask or complain about relationship pages, and suprisingly, now that I request a few links deleted, they are suddenly important?? A little weird.
Thirdly, most relationships are already described in general on character pages, most information on relationship pages would just be a repeat.
you know that i'm not saying that badly right? so you can maybe answer nicely, i'm just giving my opinion as a member of this wiki :) the relationship pages are not new and i'm not complaining about them, i'm saying that i like them and i don't think that i'm the only one. what the other's wiki are doing is absolutly not irrelevant, it's a big community and i think that it's interesting to see what the others are doing to see if we can adapt some good ideas to our wiki, to improve it. In my opinion, we should delete the few line of each relationships in general character profiles and edit special relationship pages with more informations, analysis and pictures. but that's just my opinion
I was not trying to be mean. Each wiki is a seperate community with their own policy and rules. Just look at different charmed wikis, each have different names for powers etc. No wiki is the same.
Relationship pages are just useless in my opinion, since they only repeat info with subjective/opinionated additions. I have never seen a relationship page that was not subjective, opinionated and chaotic.
but maybe this pages can be only the story of facts? personally i think that ther are really interesting so maybe we could do a vote to see what the others users are thinking of this pages? what do you think ? :)
OK, if you two are gonna continue to argue about this, please have the decency do it on your walls. And frankly, I haven't started writing any articles; they're simply dead links I have not decided to start or not. And I believe whatever I do decide should be up to me. So Jan and Marcia, please be so kind as to further your discussions on your walls and then leave me a message when you two find common agreement.
So you complain about us using your wall (which was obviously wrong, I admit), but now you're just not responding to a request? That is sort-of rude as well. Unless a a big majority suddenly wants these pages, they are not being created and they are just dead links.
Hello! Please, while undoing somebody edits, turn your Caps Lock off. Also, it has been decided on his talk page, that his birth date is in October. Please read the talk page, and in case you are still going to have objections, feel free to add your opinion there, I will gladly answer.
Second, I was the one who actually wrote the date with a little calculation. Chris was born 2 days early, not 1 month. He was conceived on Wyatt's birthday which was in February. And the pregnancy is around 9 months, which puts the date in November. The 16th day is actually a correspondence to May 16, the date when the season 6 finale was aired, which was also the episode where Chris was born.
I'm sorry, caps lock or shift, doesn't really matter, the "forget it" was all in caps so... :D
Read the talk page. The pregnancy usually last 40 weeks. There is an online calculator, where you write the date of conception, and it shows you when you are due. he was conceived on February 2nd, and his due date is October 25th. Of course, every pregnancy is different and it's hard to tell the exact due date, but I think it's obvious his due date must be in October.
Also, the fact he was born on 16th is a speculation. Just because an episode aired on the May 16th, that does not mean he was born on 16th. The episode when Wyatt was born aired on February 16th, and we know that he was born on February 2nd. Unless it will be stated in the comics that Chris was born on 16th (I doubt that), we can't have that date there.