- Brooke: "Well, then we all know why Andrea chose the rabbit."
- Andrea: "Just keep your fingers clear. He scratches."
- — the girls discussing the rabbit.[src]
On Valentine's Day in 2000, Andrea and the other girls tried to perform a spell to turn animals into men. Andrea chose a rabbit, presumably because of their breeding habits. When their attempt failed, they used a recording of Phoebe casting another version of the spell, which worked.
The transformed animals quickly turned violent and realized the magic was only temporary. In order to remain human, they tried to find Phoebe. The Snake then bit Andrea and Brooke, poisoning them in order to use them as leverage. While the animals entered P3, Prue and Piper found the girls in a car trunk and ensured they got to the hospital to be treated.
Andrea appeared in a total of 1 episode throughout the course of the series.
- Season 2
- Animal Pragmatism
|Innocents of Season 2|
|INNOCENTS SAVED||Jenny Gordon · Tina Hitchens and Masselin's Other Victims · Owen Grant · Kyle Gwydion · Eric Bragg · Ben Bragg · Marcy Steadwell · Max · Cindy · Unnamed Cupid · Matthew van Lewen · Alexandra van Lewen · Martha van Lewen · Nathan · Andrea · Brooke · Tessa · Christina Larson · Bane Jessup · Maggie Murphy · Cleavant Wilson · Sally "Bones" Dopler · Benny Ritter|
|INNOCENTS LOST||Gorgeous Man · Inspector Smith · Ryan · Treasure Hunter · Betty · Joshua, Heather and Michael · Mrs. Johnson · Sam Wilder · Martha van Lewen · Gilbert van Lewen · Concerned Citizen · Gail Altman · Helen · Amanda · Charlene Hughes · Dr. Curtis Williamson|